"Dam, old comment deleted itself somehow...

Anyway, try with nutella instead!
Get back to me with your outcomes please and especially anyone who has tried with nutella like I have before. :)"

"Ps. If I remember correctly, when made with nutella I don't think its very easy or even at all possible to change the colour with food dyes, as its very dark already. Peanut butters lighter.

But if you don't mind, I hope you try it! They don't have to be for Halloween necessarily. "

"From what I can remember. these were fantastic!
I'm hoping this recipe is still getting reviews and hopefully some of the people that posted all these reviews check in from time to time.

Just a suggestion, I made these with my friends in high school and many of us couldn't stomach the idea of using peanut butter, so we used nutella instead! It was a great idea in the end! Turned out very well. Even better than our peers who stuck with using peanut butter. So I really hope some of you try this out and find it as enjoyable as my friends and I did!

Also, I was curious to know if anyone has substituted peanut butter for nutella...
If so, would love your feedback and the changes you made in the old recipe to suit, as I cannot seem to find the one I made with nutella. Thanks.

Happy cooking! :-)"