"Amazing! My beloved said they were the best cookies she's had in a VERY long time! Follow recipe as is..and don't be turned off by the sour milk smell the buttermilk glaze makes while cooking..its SO tasty when done! I sprinkled top with raw sugar"

"FANTASTIC!! I followed reviewer's suggestions and increased pumpkin to one cup. And they took twice as long to cook..not sure how they could possibly cook in 12 min..mine took 24 min. But they were moist and wonderful..I didn't bother with the icing since they are SO sweet. Will make again!

"Followed the recipe exactly because I hadn't read any reviews..and even forgot to stir it until the last hour..and it turned out amazing! I did let it cook on low an extra hour..so 1 hour on high, 3 on low...it wasn't done at the 2 hour mark. Came out perfect and really, really yummy. I would definitely make it again and not change a thing!

"Followed the recipe exactly because I hadn't read any reviews..and even forgot to stir it until the last hour..and it turned out amazing! I did let it cook on low an extra hour..so 1 hour on high, 3 on low...it wasn't done at the 2 hour mark. Came out perfect and really, really yummy. I would definitely make it again and not change a thing!

"Followed the recipe exactly because I hadn't read any reviews..and even forgot to stir it until the last hour..and it turned out amazing! I did let it cook on low an extra hour..so 1 hour on high, 3 on low...it wasn't done at the 2 hour mark. Came out perfect and really, really yummy. I would definitely make it again and not change a thing!