My Profile


North Merrick, New York

Member since May 2009

Flag This ProfileFlag as Inappropriate

Reviewed black and white cookies

Jun 18, 2014 on

I haven't tried the recipe (which is why I'm giving it a neutral 3-star rating), but it sounds to me like the reviewers have never had a genuine New York black-and-white cookie. It's supposed to have a cake-like texture, like a firm sponge cake, or a whoopie pie. It's much softer than shortbread or a sugar cookie. The icing is supposed to harden into...

Not what you're looking for? Try: